Carrie-Anne Moss Shocked by Fan Reaction to Jedi Death in The Acolyte

Carrie-Anne Moss addressed fans' disappointment over her character's abrupt demise in the Disney+ Star Wars series The Acolyte, confessing she hadn't anticipated the strong reaction.

The premiere episode, "Lost / Found," immediately thrusts viewers into intense action as a hooded assassin (Amandla Stenberg) — later identified as Osha's twin sister Mae — confronts Moss' Jedi Master Indara in a cantina. When Mae dares Indara to fight at full strength, their ensuing duel ends with Indara's shocking defeat, leaving some fans dismayed by the rapid exit of an actress of Moss' caliber.

Showrunner Leslye Headland defended the creative decision, explaining the death was crucial for establishing high stakes and the vulnerability of the Jedi Order.

"As a filmmaker, I believed the cold open needed to make a visceral impact," Headland told GamesRadar last year. "We had to show Jedi suffering losses while maintaining moral ambiguity. The violence had to feel raw and immediate."

"Even when expected, the moment wasn't about surprise," she added. "It was about blending emotional weight with physical combat. Carrie-Anne delivered both—her performance elevated every aspect, from the duel's choreography to Indara's final moments."

Post-episode, social media erupted with critiques. Many lamented Moss' limited screen time, while others questioned her prominent marketing presence despite the early exit.

Why yall make Carrie-Anne Moss get out of bed if you’re just gonna waste her like that #theacolyte pic.twitter.com/d58TJbacI1

— Boka MAX (Formerly “Boka”) (@BokaLaBoca) June 5, 2024

In a Business Insider interview, Moss shared she'd known about Indara's fate from signing but misjudged fan investment: "The backlash made me realize my oversight. As an actor, I focus on serving the story. In hindsight, I should've recognized how audiences would feel."

Though flashbacks revisit Indara later, many fans remained frustrated. Disney's subsequent cancellation after Season 1 left narrative threads—including Darth Plagueis' live-action debut—potentially unresolved.

Ranking Star Wars' Disney+ Live-Action Series

View 8 Images

Cast members continue advocating for renewal. Manny Jacinto (Qimir) hinted at expanded Darth Plagueis arcs, cautiously noting: "We could return." Lee Jung-Jae (Sol) expressed shock at the cancellation, contrary to Stenberg's more resigned response: "Given the toxic backlash since announcement, this outcome isn't surprising."

Jodie Turner-Smith (Mother Aniseya) criticized Disney's silence amid racist online attacks: "Studios must protect actors from hate campaigns." Jacinto remains hopeful, calling Season 2 his "passion project" post-cancellation.

IGN rated The Acolyte 6/10, critiquing: "While offering fascinating glimpses into Star Wars' High Republic era, uneven writing and constrained storytelling dilute its potential. Still, its lightsaber combat delivers classic franchise excitement."